01 · The Perspective
A deposit at midnight
The story below is illustrative, built from the patterns in our sources. It is not about a real person.
Meena's father is 74 and has an Ayushman Vay Vandana card. At 11 pm he has chest pain.
The first hospital on the list says its Ayushman services are suspended. The second says it is empanelled only for orthopaedics. At the third, the desk says the Arogya Mitra comes in the morning. Until then, she must pay a deposit, "to be refunded later". She pays.
Her father was eligible. He was admitted only because she paid.
02 · The Perspective
A vast scheme, a narrow door
Ayushman Bharat Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana is enormous. The government reports more than 48.51 crore Ayushman cards and 13.25 crore hospital admissions worth ₹2.03 lakh crore. It offers cashless cover of up to ₹5 lakh per family a year, for 1,961 procedures across 27 specialties. Since it was extended to every citizen aged 70 and above, more than 1.36 crore Vay Vandana cards have been issued.
The door is another story. In July 2025, a Mumbai woman called all 24 hospitals listed under the scheme across Mumbai, Navi Mumbai and Thane for her 80-year-old father. Ten said they were not empanelled. Others covered only certain conditions. She paid the bills herself.
In Bengaluru, Citizen Matters reported that Arogya Mitras work general shifts, so patients who arrive at night may have to pay to be admitted, with no certainty about the refund. At a private empanelled hospital, a 75-year-old Vay Vandana cardholder was told benefits applied only to the general ward.
Hospitals are leaving too. 609 private hospitals have opted out since 2018, citing low reimbursement rates, delayed payments and operational problems. In August 2025, nearly 600 hospitals in Haryana stopped accepting Ayushman patients, saying the state owed them about ₹500 crore.
The evidence
609 private hospitals have left Ayushman Bharat
Private hospitals that opted out of PM-JAY since 2018, top five states
609 private hospitals have opted out of PM-JAY since 2018; Gujarat alone accounts for 233. Source: Rajya Sabha reply by the Minister of State for Health, reported by Medical Dialogues (1 April 2025). See article sources →
The five states shown account for 532 of the 609 exits. Hospitals cited low reimbursement rates, delayed payments and operational problems.
View original chart →03 · The Perspective
What India has already built
- One card, cashless cover. Up to ₹5 lakh per family a year, now including every citizen aged 70 and above.
- A large hospital network. More than 38,000 public and private hospitals were empanelled as of 31 August 2026.
- Help on the ground. Arogya Mitras at empanelled hospitals, and a 24x7 toll-free helpline, 14555.
- AI against fraud. The National Health Authority's AI-based anti-fraud system flags suspicious claims within 24 hours; 2,359 hospitals had been de-empanelled and 1,200 suspended by 31 May 2026.
- A payment rule. Hospitals are meant to be paid within 15 days.
04 · The Perspective
The door nobody sees
The trouble is not a lack of cards or hospitals. It is that the scheme cannot see the hospital door.
A list shows which hospitals are empanelled, not which are admitting cardholders for a condition this week. In March 2024, Scroll found that 6,551 hospitals had been inactive since empanelment, and 3,543 had admitted no one under the scheme in six months.
The published figures count cards issued and admissions paid for. They do not count the people turned away at the desk or asked for a deposit.
And payment runs late. The same report found that only 5% of payments in Gujarat were made within the 15-day rule, and in at least 10 states more than half of claims took longer than 45 days. When money comes late, hospitals pause or leave, and families pay.
The anti-fraud system is built to catch hospitals that over-claim. We could find no equivalent check on patients who are turned away or charged.
05 · The BIBD proposal
Card to Care
A design to test. Not a claim of achieved outcomes.
We propose Card to Care, a layer on top of the scheme's existing systems. It does not change who is eligible or what packages pay.
A Live Admit Map.
For each hospital and condition, show whether it has actually been admitting cardholders recently, from its own pre-authorisations.
Admit or Hand Over.
A hospital that cannot admit logs the reason in one tap. Before the family leaves, the system confirms the next bed, and arranges an ambulance in an emergency. No one leaves with only a "no".
Arogya Mitra 24x7.
A state-run phone desk covers every hospital at night and on holidays, and confirms that no deposit is needed.
A Zero-Pay Receipt.
At discharge, an SMS and voice message in the patient's language: what the scheme paid, and that they owe nothing for covered care. Any payment can be reported with a missed call.
A Fair-Pay Clock.
Hospitals see each claim's stage and days against the 15-day rule. Late interest is paid automatically, and every deduction carries a reason.
A Card to Care Index.
Each district publishes, every month, how many cardholders were admitted at the first or second hospital, refusals by reason, payments reported by patients, and claims paid on time.
06 · Design + AI
What AI can do here, and what it must not
AI can infer which hospitals are really admitting for each condition, find the nearest likely bed in minutes, and spot patterns of refusals and charges.
It must never refuse a patient, reject a claim or penalise a hospital on its own, and patients who report a payment must never be refused later. People decide.
07 · A testable next step
Start with one district
A 12-month pilot in one district, such as Karnal in Haryana, compared with a similar district, can test the whole journey. Our planning estimate is ₹2 to 3.5 crore, excluding claims, interest and refunds.
08 · Who must act
What each of us can do
| Families: | if you are asked to pay with an Ayushman card, report it on 14555 and keep the receipt. |
|---|---|
| The National Health Authority: | show which hospitals have admitted cardholders for each condition recently, and add a one-tap refusal log. |
| State health agencies: | start a night-time Arogya Mitra phone desk, and publish claims paid within 15 days, by hospital. |
| Empanelled hospitals: | give every cardholder a written zero-payment statement at discharge. |
| District collectors: | review a monthly Card to Care Index with hospitals and patient groups. |
09 · The Perspective
A card should lead to a bed
India has built the hardest parts: a card for crores of families and tens of thousands of hospitals. The next step is to see the door. A card should lead to a bed, not to 24 phone calls, a night deposit or a bill at discharge.
Watch the full episode: Redesigning Ayushman Bharat: Eligible Is Not Admitted